I have never talked about this with anyone since it has happened.
About 20 years ago I went with my brother and a couple of his friends to an old barn just outside of town that was supposedly being used a satanic church. There was nothing but cornfields on the right side of the road. On the left side there was old farm house with an old graveyard to the side of it. As we passed that there was satanic writing all over the road. Just off the road past the graveyard and farmhouse was the barn. It was pretty covered up with weeds and brush and was barely visible. As we got closer to the barn, you could see there was writing all over it as well.
I was only 15 or 16 at the time so I wasn't about to go inside this place. I went back to the car. My brother proceeded to go inside. His 2 friends went back and stood by the car as they weren't about to try to go inside either. This was a pretty isolated place and we hadn't passed a car on the way there for miles. It was pretty late at night as well.
My brother was gone maybe a couple of minutes when we saw headlights coming up the road. We yelled for my brother to come out so we could leave. We were all on edge anyway just being there and now there was a car coming down the road. My brother came out and we all hurriedly got in the car and my brother took off back in the direction that we came which was directly toward these headlights. As we got closer the lights got brighter. When we got about 50 yards from the lights... They vanished. There was no turnoffs, just this old farmhouse, graveyard, and cornfields. The lights did not turn, just vanished. My brother said there was pews in the barn and was set up like a church. He said it was pretty dark so he couldn't see much.
I have tried to look up hauntings in Reily Township, Ohio but the only thing that I have found so far was one sight that said many of the graveyards in this area were haunted.